Karnataka coalition crisis: Supreme Court to pronounce verdict at 10 30 am on Wednesday (July 17)

Karnataka coalition crisis Live Updates

The Supreme Court will continue hearing the case on Karnataka MLAs resigning. 

3:24 PM IST

Supreme Court reserves its order for Wednesday (July 17)

After hearing the arguments put forth from all sides, the SC has reserved its verdict. The top court will pronounce its verdict at 10 30 pm on Wednesday (July 17). 

3:05 PM IST

Ploy to fell government much before budget presentation: Rajiv Dhawan

Rajiv Dhawan says that the rebel MLAs were conspiring to fell the government much before the budget presenation. 

2:53 PM IST

'Understand the malafide intention behind resignations': Rajiv Dhawan

SC must trust the Speaker and his intentions, It should examine the malafide intention of the MLAs to resign: Rajiv Dhawan 

2:34 PM IST

Rajiv Dhawan urges court to quash the case

It's a tussle between chief ministers, one former and the other, incumbent. There is no fight between the rebel MLAs and the Speaker. Please don't entertain such pleas, says Rajiv Dhawan.

2:30 PM IST

Rajiv Dhawan says SC can't direct Speaker

Rajiv Dhawan reiterates that SC can't direct Speaker in this case 

2:28 PM IST

Mukul jumps in, says Rajiv's arguments are wrong

Mukul Rohatgi objects to Rajiv's arguments, says MLAs were not enticed

2:26 PM IST

'Rebel MLAs being coerced to resign,' says Rajiv Dhawan

Rajiv Dhawan says those who have put in their papers have been enticed with offers and ministerships 

2:23 PM IST

Rajiv Dhawan, HD Kumaraswamy's lawyer begins argument

Chief minister HD Kumaraswamy's counsel Rajiv Dhawan begins his arguments at the Supreme Court 

2:20 PM IST

CJI re-emphasises that MLAs have the right to resign

CJI Ranjan Gogoi reiterates that it is the fundamental right of the MLAs to tender resignation: CJI Ranjan Gogoi 

2:19 PM IST

Tenth Schedule being used to harass MLAs?

Are you using the tenth schedule of the Indian Constitution to intimidate rebel MLAs?: CJI Ranjan Gogoi 

2:17 PM IST

Resignation a route to disqualification?

CJI wonders as to why resignations are being viewed as a route to disqualification 

2:11 PM IST

SC resumes hearing in Karnataka MLAs resigning case

The SC has resumed its hearing on the case related to KarnatakaMLAs resigning 

1:01 PM IST

Proceedings to continue at 2 pm as judges take lunch break

Hearing on the case relating to Karnataka MLAs resigning to continue at 2 pm as judges take a lunch break 

12:54 PM IST

Abhishek Singhvi pleads SC to vacate 'status quo' order

Abhishek Singhvi pleads with the SC to vacate 'status quo' order and reassures that the Speaker will take a call by tomorrow.    

12:44 PM IST

Abhishek Singhvi blames BJP for tturmoil in Karnataka

BJP has a role to play in the political mess in Karnataka: Abhishek Singhvi 

12:43 PM IST

Speaker Ramesh Kumat to decide by tomorrow?

By tomorrow (July 17), Speaker will decide on resignations and disqualification: Abhishk Singhvi 

12:21 PM IST

CJI Ranjan Gogoi questions Abhishek over Speaker's silence

Why was the Speaker quiet until the rebel MLAs approached the Supreme Court?: CJI Ranjan Gogoi 

12:18 PM IST

CJI Ranjan Gogoi wonders why resignations not accepted

Resignations were given on July 11. Why have they not been accepted till date? Why are you delaying it?: CJI Ranjan Gogoi 

12:15 PM IST

CJI questions Abhishek Singhvi over non-acceptance of resignations

CJI asks Abhishek as to why Ramesh Kumar did not accept resignations when the MLAs said they tried to meet him, but he was not available.

12:13 PM IST

Even after our direction, why didn’t the Speaker take any decision earlier?: CJI Ranjan Gogoi

Even after our direction, why didn’t the Speaker take any decision earlier?: CJI Ranjan Gogoi 

12:11 PM IST

Four MLAs have not appeared before the Speaker: Abhishek Singhvi

Four MLAs have not appeared before the Speaker. It is imperative that MLAs appear in person to submit resignations: Abhishek Singhvi 

12:09 PM IST

MLAs have resigned with a view to escaping disqualification: Abhishek Singhvi

MLAs have resigned with a view to escaping disqualification: Abhishek Singhvi

12:07 PM IST

Can’t hear the case overnight and decide it: Abhishek Singhvi

Can’t  hear the case overnight and decide it: Abhishek Singhvi

12:05 PM IST

Speaker has the right to decide on resignations: Abhishek Singhvi

Speaker has the right to decide on resignations: Abhishek Singhvi

12:03 PM IST

Counsel for Speaker Ramesh Kumar Abhishek Singhvi starts his arguments

Abhishek Singhvi says Speaker has already started the procedure for accepting resignations. He adds that the MLAs have not appeared before the Speaker 

11:58 AM IST

Mukul Rohatgi reads out verdict by Justice AK Sikri, delivered in May 2018

Mukul Rohatgi, counsel for rebel MLAs, reads out verdict given by Justice AK Sikri in relation to former CM Yeddyurappa's swearing-in that took place in May 2018

11:54 AM IST

MLAs have a million reasons to resign, says Mukul Rohatgi

Mukul Rohatgi says rebel MLAs have a million reasons to resign; CJI left shocked at this statement 

11:49 AM IST

CJI also says Speaker can't delay accepting resignations

Though CJI Ranjan Gogoi said SC can't direct Speaker, but it added that the Speaker can't delay accepting resignations 

11:46 AM IST

CJI says can't pressure Speaker to do anything

Has the Speaker Ramesh Kumar got an upper hand? During hearing CJI Ranjan Gogoi says SC can't direct Speaker to do anything. 

11:33 AM IST

'Rebel MLAs have no intention to become ministers in other governments'

Mukul Rohatgi argues that the rebel MLAs have no intention to join other parties and become ministers 

11:30 AM IST

Speaker has no evidence to disqualify rebel MLAs: Mukul Rohatgi

Speaker has no evidence to disqualify rebel MLAs, says Mukul Rohatgi 

11:20 AM IST

Rebel MLAs being intimidated to vote in favour of coalition: Mukul Rohatgi

Mukul Rohatgi says rebel MLAs being intimidated to vote in favour of 

11:06 AM IST

Party defection is not the aim of rebel MLAs: Mukul Rohatgi

Rebel MLAs have no intention to defect parties, says Mukul Rohatgi 

11:04 AM IST

Fundamental right for the MLAs to resign: Mukul Rohatgi

Mukul Rohatgi says it is the fundamental right of  the rebel MLAs to resign. He added Speaker can't question it. As resignations were submitted first, Speaker should decide on resignations first. 

11:00 AM IST

Mukul Rohatgi wonders why rebel MLAs' resignation not accepted

Mukul Rohatgi says when the resignation of Umesh Jadhav (ex-MLA, Kalaburagi) can be accepted, why not those of rebel MLAs? There was disqualfication threat against him as well, but why was his resignation accepted? 

10:57 AM IST

Mukul Rohatgi says all MLAs have submitted handwritten resignations

Mukul Rohatgi, counself for rebel MLAs says they have submitted handwritten resignations and not faxed them to the Speaker 

10:55 AM IST

Mukul Rohatgi says SC has right to direct Speaker

Mukul Rohatgi, counsel for rebel MLAs says Court can direct Speaker 

10:54 AM IST

Hearing begins

SC bench headed by CJI Ranjan Gogoi begins 

10:32 AM IST

Lawyers, judges arrive at the Supreme Court

Lawyers, Abhishek and Rajiv Dhawan and judges arrive at the Supreme Court. The hearing is all set to begin. 

10:31 AM IST

Congress MLA Krishna Byre Gowda arrives at Supreme Court

Congress MLA Krishna Byre Gowda, who is a minister for rural development, arrives at the Supreme Court 

3:27 PM IST:

After hearing the arguments put forth from all sides, the SC has reserved its verdict. The top court will pronounce its verdict at 10 30 pm on Wednesday (July 17). 

3:05 PM IST:

Rajiv Dhawan says that the rebel MLAs were conspiring to fell the government much before the budget presenation. 

2:53 PM IST:

SC must trust the Speaker and his intentions, It should examine the malafide intention of the MLAs to resign: Rajiv Dhawan 

2:35 PM IST:

It's a tussle between chief ministers, one former and the other, incumbent. There is no fight between the rebel MLAs and the Speaker. Please don't entertain such pleas, says Rajiv Dhawan.

2:30 PM IST:

Rajiv Dhawan reiterates that SC can't direct Speaker in this case 

2:28 PM IST:

Mukul Rohatgi objects to Rajiv's arguments, says MLAs were not enticed

2:29 PM IST:

Rajiv Dhawan says those who have put in their papers have been enticed with offers and ministerships 

2:23 PM IST:

Chief minister HD Kumaraswamy's counsel Rajiv Dhawan begins his arguments at the Supreme Court 

2:21 PM IST:

CJI Ranjan Gogoi reiterates that it is the fundamental right of the MLAs to tender resignation: CJI Ranjan Gogoi 

2:19 PM IST:

Are you using the tenth schedule of the Indian Constitution to intimidate rebel MLAs?: CJI Ranjan Gogoi 

2:18 PM IST:

CJI wonders as to why resignations are being viewed as a route to disqualification 

2:12 PM IST:

The SC has resumed its hearing on the case related to KarnatakaMLAs resigning 

1:03 PM IST:

Hearing on the case relating to Karnataka MLAs resigning to continue at 2 pm as judges take a lunch break 

12:57 PM IST:

Abhishek Singhvi pleads with the SC to vacate 'status quo' order and reassures that the Speaker will take a call by tomorrow.    

12:44 PM IST:

BJP has a role to play in the political mess in Karnataka: Abhishek Singhvi 

12:43 PM IST:

By tomorrow (July 17), Speaker will decide on resignations and disqualification: Abhishk Singhvi 

12:21 PM IST:

Why was the Speaker quiet until the rebel MLAs approached the Supreme Court?: CJI Ranjan Gogoi 

12:19 PM IST:

Resignations were given on July 11. Why have they not been accepted till date? Why are you delaying it?: CJI Ranjan Gogoi 

12:15 PM IST:

CJI asks Abhishek as to why Ramesh Kumar did not accept resignations when the MLAs said they tried to meet him, but he was not available.

12:13 PM IST:

Even after our direction, why didn’t the Speaker take any decision earlier?: CJI Ranjan Gogoi 

12:11 PM IST:

Four MLAs have not appeared before the Speaker. It is imperative that MLAs appear in person to submit resignations: Abhishek Singhvi 

12:09 PM IST:

MLAs have resigned with a view to escaping disqualification: Abhishek Singhvi

12:07 PM IST:

Can’t  hear the case overnight and decide it: Abhishek Singhvi

12:05 PM IST:

Speaker has the right to decide on resignations: Abhishek Singhvi

12:03 PM IST:

Abhishek Singhvi says Speaker has already started the procedure for accepting resignations. He adds that the MLAs have not appeared before the Speaker 

11:59 AM IST:

Mukul Rohatgi, counsel for rebel MLAs, reads out verdict given by Justice AK Sikri in relation to former CM Yeddyurappa's swearing-in that took place in May 2018

11:55 AM IST:

Mukul Rohatgi says rebel MLAs have a million reasons to resign; CJI left shocked at this statement 

11:50 AM IST:

Though CJI Ranjan Gogoi said SC can't direct Speaker, but it added that the Speaker can't delay accepting resignations 

11:46 AM IST:

Has the Speaker Ramesh Kumar got an upper hand? During hearing CJI Ranjan Gogoi says SC can't direct Speaker to do anything. 

11:34 AM IST:

Mukul Rohatgi argues that the rebel MLAs have no intention to join other parties and become ministers 

11:31 AM IST:

Speaker has no evidence to disqualify rebel MLAs, says Mukul Rohatgi 

11:25 AM IST:

Mukul Rohatgi says rebel MLAs being intimidated to vote in favour of 

11:10 AM IST:

Rebel MLAs have no intention to defect parties, says Mukul Rohatgi 

11:05 AM IST:

Mukul Rohatgi says it is the fundamental right of  the rebel MLAs to resign. He added Speaker can't question it. As resignations were submitted first, Speaker should decide on resignations first. 

11:01 AM IST:

Mukul Rohatgi says when the resignation of Umesh Jadhav (ex-MLA, Kalaburagi) can be accepted, why not those of rebel MLAs? There was disqualfication threat against him as well, but why was his resignation accepted? 

10:58 AM IST:

Mukul Rohatgi, counself for rebel MLAs says they have submitted handwritten resignations and not faxed them to the Speaker 

10:56 AM IST:

Mukul Rohatgi, counsel for rebel MLAs says Court can direct Speaker 

10:55 AM IST:

SC bench headed by CJI Ranjan Gogoi begins 

10:35 AM IST:

Lawyers, Abhishek and Rajiv Dhawan and judges arrive at the Supreme Court. The hearing is all set to begin. 

10:32 AM IST:

Congress MLA Krishna Byre Gowda, who is a minister for rural development, arrives at the Supreme Court